An open definitionVersion 0.2, draftStarted by Æmotion Studio, maker of Mæstræa
Sold Open
Sold Open software is sold, and it comes open. You pay for the build and the work behind it, and every copy comes with its complete source code under an open-source licence, so it’s yours to keep, change and share.
Pay for the work, not the permission.
Transcript of The Receipt
[A closed steel padlock on plain paper.] Most software you buy is a permission.
[A small black box with an amber status light, blinking.] It checks in with a server, [the light flickers and goes out] it stops when a subscription lapses, [later, the box is gone, leaving a clean outline in the dust] and it disappears when its maker moves on.
[The padlock again, in dimmer light, closing in on its keyhole.] You paid for it, but you can’t open it, fix it or keep it running.
[Text: “Open. The ownership half: solved long ago. Anyone with a copy may use, study, change and share it.”] Open-source licences solved the ownership half long ago. [Text: “Sold. Getting paid: never settled.”] What they never settled is how the people who make the software get paid.
[The padlock clicks open and turns into a red Sold Open price tag.] Sold Open puts the two halves together.
[A printer prints an example receipt: official build, $25.00; permission fee, $0.00; complete source code, right to change it and right to share it, included; activation keys, none; expires, never.] You pay for the build and the work behind it. Every copy comes with its complete source code, under an open-source licence, so it’s yours to keep, change and share.
[The cut receipt, stamped “Sold Open”. Text: “The price is illustrative.”] Sharing isn’t a loss. Enough people pay; not everyone has to.
[The red tag. Text: “Makers: use the badge. No permission needed while your copies meet the clauses.”]
[End card: “The Sold Open Definition, version 0.2 (draft)”, the Sold Open badge, “Read the definition: soldopen.org”.] Sold Open. Pay for the work, not the permission.
Sold Open software
Example receipt
| Official build, Example App 1.4 | $25.00 |
|---|---|
| Permission fee | $0.00 |
| Complete source code | included |
| Right to change it | included |
| Right to share it (see the note below) | included |
| Activation keys | none |
| Expires | never |
| Updates and support | as stated |
| Total | $25.00 |
Thank you. Keep it, change it, share it.
For the software. Content, third-party parts, and names and logos may carry other terms, listed where it’s sold.
Who it’s for
People who make software, and people who buy it
Makers
You sell software and want your buyers to own what they pay for: the build, the source, and the right to change and share it. Sold Open gives that promise a name and a standard anyone can check.
Buyers
You’re deciding what to trust. Of the eight promises the name makes, three you can check yourself: the source comes with the download, the licence is open, and nothing checks whether you paid.
Not for
Donation-only open-source projects: with no price, they aren’t sold (clause 1). Services with nothing to download have no copy to open.
Why
Buying software should mean getting all of it
Most software you buy is a permission. It checks in with a server, it stops when a subscription lapses, and it disappears when its maker moves on. You paid for it, but you can’t open it, fix it or keep it running.
Open-source licences solved the ownership half long ago: anyone who has a copy may use it, study it, change it and share it. What they never settled is how the people who make the software get paid, and too often open came to mean unpaid.
Sold Open puts the two halves together. You pay the maker for a copy and the work behind it, and the copy you get is complete and yours.
Paid makers can keep making, and open copies let the work keep growing after any one maker stops.
- 01Buying should mean getting the whole thing.
- 02Open doesn’t mean unpaid.
- 03Charge for the work, never for the rights: using, changing and sharing always come with it.
- 04Sharing isn’t a loss. Enough people pay; not everyone has to.
- 05Software should be able to outlive its maker. When one maker stops, anyone with a copy can carry it on.
- 06Say plainly what the money pays for.
Where this is going
Every copy is a seed
Transcript of Save File
[A chat window late at night. Sam: “remember Lantern Garden??” The reply: “yes. I still play it”. A small pixel-art game opens: a lantern-lit path over a hill at night.] You find a game you can’t put down. A tool that just clicks.
[The game freezes and turns grey. A message: “This game is no longer supported. Lantern Garden can’t be started.” The player closes it and tries again, and the message comes straight back.] And then one day, it stops. The makers move on, and it’s stuck right where they left it.
[Chat: “wait, it just died??” Sam types, then: “they re-released it Sold Open. comes with the source”, with a link to Lantern Garden.] What if it didn’t have to stop?
[A store page: Lantern Garden by Little Lamp Games, marked “Sold Open”, “Source included” and “Yours to keep”. The player buys it. A receipt: “Paid to the makers. Thank you.” On the makers’ dashboard: “New supporter”.] Sold Open is a new way to buy software. You pay the people who make it, so they can keep making great things.
[“Download complete”. The Downloads folder holds the game and a folder named SOURCE. The player opens player.lua and changes jump_height from 2 to 6.] And you get something you never got before: the whole thing. Every copy comes with its source. It’s yours to keep, to open up, to learn from and to change.
[They run their build, and the character jumps far higher. Chat: “changed one number. look at this jump”. Sam: “wait till you see what people are making”. Text: “a year later”. Little Lamp Games posts: “We’re moving on to our next project. The source is yours. Thank you.” A versions page fills, player counts climbing: Night Market (co-op for two), a Japanese translation, a Community patch (bugs fixed by players) and a Speedrun Edition (a mod with a timer and new routes).] So when the makers move on, the work doesn’t end. Players pick it up. Fans fix it, mod it and take it places nobody imagined.
[More versions appear as tiles. Sam: “made my own one”, with a link to Firefly Valley.] Every copy is a seed, and every good idea gets a chance to keep growing.
[The Sold Open badge, and three lines in turn.] Pay the people who make it. Keep what you buy. Help it grow.
[End card: “The Sold Open Definition · version 0.2 (draft)”, “Pay for the work, not the permission.”, the badge, “Read the definition”, soldopen.org, “Started by Æmotion Studio”.] Sold Open. Pay for the work, not the permission.
[The desktop, the store, Lantern Garden, Little Lamp Games, Sam and the fan versions are invented for this film.]
This section is the view of Æmotion Studio, who started Sold Open. The definition below doesn’t depend on it.
You find a piece of software you love, or a game you can’t put down. Then development stops. The developers move on, and there’s nothing you can do. The program stays where it was left, and the idea stays trapped in time, with no room to grow into something more useful or more fun.
Sold Open is a way to change that.
The people who make it get paid. The people who build the tools you rely on can sustain themselves. You can’t expect the fruit to grow if you don’t water the roots.
The work outlives its makers. Every copy comes with its source, so when the makers move on, the work can be carried on, improved and taken in many directions, by many hands, not just one.
You get the whole thing. Not just permission to use it, but the thing itself: yours to keep, to open up, to learn from and to change.
The point is a tree whose branches never stop growing. Every copy is a seed.
Æmotion Studio, who started Sold Open
The definition · version 0.2
The Sold Open Definition
Transcript of Sold Open in 90 seconds
[A printed sheet. Text: “Most software you buy is a permission.” Below it, “Open it, fix it, keep it running” is struck through, one line at a time.] Most software you buy is a permission. You can’t open it, fix it or keep it running.
[A rubber stamp lands: “Sold Open”. The struck lines become “Keep it, change it, share it”.] Sold Open software is sold, and it comes open.
[The motto alone.] Pay for the work, not the permission.
[A large red counter rolls through the eight clauses of the definition, one every seven seconds.]
[1: A price. Pay-what-you-want counts if its minimum is above zero.] At least one official way to get it costs money. Free copies are fine too.
[2: Open licence. OSI-approved or FSF-listed.] It comes under an open-source licence: anyone with a copy may change it and share it.
[3: Source with every copy. In the download, or right beside it.] Every copy, paid or free, comes with its complete source code, at no extra charge.
[4: Nothing held back. Apart from listed content, third-party parts, and names and logos.] Everything the maker sells for it is Sold Open too, add-ons included.
[5: Early, never exclusive. A three-month cap on how long other buyers wait.] Paying for early access can get you a release sooner, never something other buyers can’t have.
[6: Sharing is never punished. “Sharing isn’t a loss. Enough people pay; not everyone has to.”] You may share it, even early builds, and nothing happens to you if you do.
[7: Nothing switches off. No activation, no licence keys, no logins.] Nothing checks whether you paid, and nothing has a time limit, betas included.
[8: Plain terms. What the price pays for, which licence applies, how you get the source and whether it’s public.] And where it’s sold, the maker says plainly what the price pays for.
[A dark sheet with a red cross: what Sold Open isn’t.] Sold Open isn’t a licence. Not a certification. Not a claim that the source is public. Not endorsed by the Free Software Foundation or the Open Source Initiative.
[End card: the Sold Open badge, the motto, “Sold Open v0.2 (draft)”, “Read the definition: soldopen.org”, “Planned first adopter: Mæstræa”.] Use the badge while your copies meet the clauses. Pay for the work, not the permission.
Sold Open is a way of selling software, not a licence. Software is Sold Open when every copy its maker distributes under that name meets all eight clauses below. “The maker” means whoever sells the official copies, and anyone acting for them.
-
Clause 1: A price
At least one official way to get the software costs money. Pay-what-you-want counts if its minimum is above zero. Discounts, free copies and free builds are fine alongside it.
What this covers (clause 1)
Donation-only open-source projects aren’t Sold Open, and nothing is wrong with that. Hardship copies, student copies and regional prices are all fine.
-
Clause 2: Open licence
The software is released under a licence approved by the Open Source Initiative or listed as a free software licence by the Free Software Foundation. The only exceptions are those in clause 4.
What this covers (clause 2)
Clause 3 is the maker’s own promise whatever the licence says. A sole copyright holder isn’t bound by the GPL, and permissive licences such as MIT don’t require source at all. Someone who passes on an MIT build without its source is allowed to; their copies just aren’t Sold Open.
-
Clause 3: Source with every copy
Every copy, paid or free, stable or early, comes with its complete source code, in the same download or the same place, at no extra charge and with no extra steps. Complete means that exact version, in the form its developers edit, with the build and packaging scripts and exact dependency versions needed to build a working copy. Publishing the source for everyone is welcome but not required.
What this covers (clause 3)
“The same place” echoes the GPL FAQ, which says that anyone charging to download GPLv3 binaries must “offer equivalent access to the source code in the same way through the same place at no further charge”. Where a store can’t hold a source archive, a link next to the download and in the app’s About box works. “No extra steps” means no forms, requests, passwords or extra accounts. A free demo comes with its source too.
-
Clause 4: Nothing held back
Everything the maker sells for the software is Sold Open too: editions, features, plugins, add-ons, DLC, and the code behind any feature that runs on the maker’s servers. Different ways to pay for the same software may differ only in timing (clause 5), service and convenience.
Anything that runs or decides is software, wherever it’s stored: code, scripts, shaders, visual-script graphs, presets, AI prompts and model weights the maker trained. Only the following may carry other terms, and only if they’re listed where it’s sold:
- (a)content: art, music, sound, voice, video, writing, level layouts and sample libraries;
- (b)third-party parts the maker didn’t make, commission or control, which buyers can get from their owner, such as an engine, a platform SDK, a codec or someone else’s model weights;
- (c)names and logos.
With the listed third-party parts, the source must build a working copy.
What this covers (clause 4)
Content is what you see or hear; if a file runs or decides something, it’s software. Shell companies and commissioned closed libraries don’t count as third-party. A game on a commercial engine can qualify if its own code is open and the engine is listed. A fine-tune the maker trains counts as the maker’s own weights; if the base model’s licence won’t let it be opened, it can’t be part of a Sold Open copy. Other developers’ closed plugins sold alongside must be labelled as third-party, and no advertised feature may depend on them.
-
Clause 5: Early, never exclusive
Paying for early access can get you a release sooner, never something other buyers can’t have. If some paid options get a release first, every paid option that covers that version gets it within three months, and the wait is stated upfront.
What this covers (clause 5)
Unstable previews needn’t reach every paid option; the stable release that follows must. A one-time purchase that covers version 1 can exclude version 2. There is no permanent members-only version.
-
Clause 6: Sharing is never punished
Buyers may share anything the licence allows, for free or for money, including early and unstable builds and their source. The maker’s terms and store pages don’t ask them not to, and nothing happens to them if they do: no bans, lost updates, cancelled memberships, withheld support, or per-buyer watermarks or tracking. Trademark rules may require changed versions to be renamed, but must let unchanged copies be shared under their own name.
What this covers (clause 6)
The maker can still refuse service for other reasons, such as fraud or abuse. A “please don’t share” line in the terms is ruled out. So is relying on a store’s default terms that forbid sharing; the maker says otherwise in writing (clause 8).
-
Clause 7: Nothing switches off
Nothing checks whether you paid: no activation, licence keys, logins or online checks to run it. Nothing has a time limit, betas included. Ending a membership stops new downloads, never what’s already downloaded. If the software needs a server the maker runs, that server’s source comes with it (clause 4), so the software can keep working without the maker.
What this covers (clause 7)
Update checks, optional sync and downloads you ask for are fine, as long as the software runs without them. Features that rely on someone else’s service must say so where it’s sold (clause 8). A copy sold through a store with its own launcher must run without that launcher. Free demos may leave features out, as long as they say which.
-
Clause 8: Plain terms
Where it’s sold, the maker says plainly:
- what the price pays for;
- which licence applies;
- what carries other terms, and where to get the third-party parts;
- how buyers get the source, and whether it’s public;
- how long early access lasts;
- that buyers may share, even where a store’s default terms say otherwise.
What this covers (clause 8)
Some stores’ default terms forbid sharing what you buy. Under Patreon’s terms, creators give members a “revocable, limited license” for their “own private, personal, non-promotional, non-commercial use”. A Sold Open maker says on the page or post itself that buyers may share.
Where the name applies
Sold Open describes copies, not companies. If a store’s rules make a clause impossible, as some console and mobile stores’ rules do, the maker can still sell there, but those copies aren’t Sold Open. Leave the name and badge off that store, and say where the Sold Open copy is.
Citing
Cite the version and clause, for example “Sold Open v0.2, clause 6”. Each version will stay published after it’s replaced.
The first question
Is it open source if you pay to get it?
By licence, yes.
The Open Source Initiative says so in its FAQ: “You can even sell Open Source software.” The GPL FAQ asks the question directly, “If I distribute GPLed software for a fee, am I required to also make it available to the public without a charge?”, and answers:
“No. However, if someone pays your fee and gets a copy, the GPL gives them the freedom to release it to the public, with or without a fee.”
GPL FAQ, Free Software Foundation
The Open Source Definition’s own source-code clause is met by software that ships with its source: “The program must include source code, and must allow distribution in source code as well as compiled form.” (Open Source Definition, clause 2; OSI FAQ.)
By expectation, not always.
Many people read “open source” as “code I can read before I pay”. That’s a fair expectation, and Sold Open without public source doesn’t meet it. So unless your source is public, say “Sold Open” rather than “open source” wherever people expect public code. That gap is why Sold Open has its own name.
How it compares
Where Sold Open sits
Transcript of Where it sits
[Text: “How it compares. Can you charge for software, and hold nothing back?”] Can you charge for software, and hold nothing back?
[A table of seven ways to sell software becomes a line from most to least restricted, with an empty ring in the fifth place.] Seven models, roughly from most restricted to least.
[A marker stops at each model in turn, with a card answering two questions: is payment required, and is anything held back?]
[Proprietary: usually; the source, and the rights to change and share.] Proprietary: usually paid, and closed.
[Open core: for paid features; yes, paid features are closed. “Readable isn’t open.”] Open core keeps paid features closed, even readable ones. Readable isn’t open.
[Source-available (Fair Source, FSL, BUSL): for restricted uses; some uses need a paid licence until it opens.] Source-available: readable now, open later.
[Sponsorware: for early access; new features, until a funding goal is met.] Sponsorware: sponsors first, everyone after the funding goal.
[The marker hops over the empty ring. Paid builds of public source: for the ready-made build, free from source; nothing held back in the code.] Paid builds of public source sell convenience, not code.
[Donation-funded open source: no payment; nothing held back.] Donation-funded: nothing held back, and no price.
[Close-up on paper: a red Sold Open tag slides along a thread into the empty ring.] Sold Open sits here.
[The full line with the badge in the fifth place. Its trade: a real price. In exchange: nothing held back, source with every copy, sharing is never punished, nothing switches off. Footnote: content, third-party parts and names may have other terms, listed upfront.] Its trade: a real price. In exchange: nothing held back, source with every copy, sharing is never punished, nothing switches off.
[A dark room with a beam of light. Questions people ask.] If anyone can share it, why would anyone pay? For the official build, updates and support, and so there’s a next version. Sold Open needs enough people to pay, not everyone.
Is it open source if you pay to get it? [“By licence, yes.”] By licence, yes. [“By expectation, not always.”] By expectation, not always. Unless your source is public, say “Sold Open” rather than “open source” where people expect public code.
[The badge. Text: “Use the name and the badge. Sold Open v0.2. While your copies meet the clauses. No permission needed.”] Use the name and the badge while your copies meet the clauses. No permission needed.
[End card: “Read the definition”, “The Sold Open Definition, version 0.2 (draft)”, “soldopen.org”. Fine print: started by Æmotion Studio; planned first adopter, Mæstræa; narrated by a synthetic voice; music made with Stable Audio 3 Medium.] The definition is the test. Pay for the work, not the permission.
| Model | Open licence? | Source with a purchase? | Anything held back? | Sharing allowed? | Payment required? | Source public? | Keeps working if you stop paying? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Proprietary | No | No | The source, and the rights to change and share | No | Usually | No | Perpetual licences: yes. Subscriptions: often no |
| Open core | Core only | Core: public. Paid parts: no, or readable under a closed licence | Yes: paid features are closed | Core only | For paid features | Core only | Core: yes. Paid features often need an active licence |
| Source-available (Fair Source, FSL, BUSL) | Not at first; opens later (FSL after two years, BUSL within four) | Public to read; no purchase needed | Some uses need a paid licence until it opens | Yes, with the same limits on use | For restricted uses | Yes | Usually yes |
| Sponsorware | Usually | Yes: sponsors get a private repository | New features, until a funding goal is met | The licence allows it; sponsors are often asked not to | For early access | After funding goals | Yes |
| Sold Open | Yes | Yes: every copy, early builds included | Nothing of the maker’s that runs or decides. Content, third-party parts and names may have other terms, listed upfront | Yes, early builds included; never punished | For at least one official way to get it; shared copies may be free | Not required; the maker says which | Yes |
| Paid builds of public source (e.g. Ardour, Zrythm) | Yes | Yes, and public to all | Not in the code; the free official build may be limited | Yes | For the ready-made build; free from source | Yes | Yes |
| Donation-funded open source | Yes | Public to all | Nothing | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
- Proprietary: a broad category; the common thread is a licence that forbids copying and changing.
- Open core: some vendors let customers read paid-tier code under a closed licence. Readable isn’t open.
- Source-available: Fair Source asks for delayed open-source publication but sets no maximum delay; the FSL and BUSL do.
- Sponsorware: terms vary by project. Material for MkDocs Insiders asked sponsors not to distribute its source.
- Sold Open: every buyer gets the source and may publish it, but the maker doesn’t have to publish it for everyone. Unlike sponsorware, nothing is held back. That’s the trade it makes for a real price.
- Paid builds: you pay for the convenience of the official build, and the source is free to everyone. Ardour’s free build starts going silent after ten minutes; Zrythm’s is limited to 25 tracks.
- Donation-funded: also covers projects paid for by employers and foundations. Payment is optional by definition.
Good practice
Encouraged, not required
- Publish the source for everyone when you can, at release or after a delay you state.
- Prefer a copyleft licence, so changed versions stay open too.
- Don’t use “open source” tags where people expect public code, unless yours is public.
- Build the source archive in a clean environment before each release, and publish checksums so shared copies can be checked.
- Keep free builds generous enough to judge the software by.
- Promise notice before any licence change, and plan a final release if the project ends.
- Offer hardship copies to people who can’t pay.
- Never blame people who don’t pay.
Precedents and lessons
We didn’t invent this. We named it.
Each entry shaped a belief, a clause or a point of good practice.
- 1985
Richard Stallman offers to mail a tape of GNU Emacs to anyone who wants one, “for a fee of $150”. Selling free software is as old as free software.
Shaped belief 2
- 1996
The Free Software Foundation’s “Selling Free Software”: “Actually, we encourage people who redistribute free software to charge as much as they wish or can.”
Shaped clause 1
- 2016
Aseprite, a pixel-art editor that was sold as GPL software, changes its licence to stop redistribution. The community forks the last GPL-licensed code as LibreSprite.
Shaped good practice
- 2021
Qt makes the long-term-support releases of Qt 5.15 commercial-only, with open-source releases following about a year later. Developers who relied on it push back.
Shaped clause 5
- 2021
Ardour’s lead developer on its paid builds: “we do not charge for the software, but for the service of building it.” And: “it doesn’t matter if everybody pays, it only matters that enough people pay.”
Shaped belief 4
- 2023
Red Hat limits RHEL’s source to customers and partners, and reserves the right to end contracts with those who redistribute it. The Software Freedom Conservancy sums it up: “if you exercise your rights under the GPL, your money is no good here”.
Shaped clause 6
- 2025
Material for MkDocs ends its Insiders programme, which had given sponsors early features under an open licence while asking them not to distribute its source. Everything is made free for everyone.
Shaped clause 6
- 2026
37signals looks back on ONCE, which sold its Campfire chat app for a one-time fee, with the source code but under a licence that didn’t allow sharing it. David Heinemeier Hansson: “The original concept for ONCE sought to sell self-hostable web apps for a one-time fee. That didn’t work.” Campfire is now free and MIT-licensed.
- 2026
The European citizens’ initiative Stop Destroying Videogames is submitted to the European Commission with 1,294,188 verified statements of support. On 16 June the Commission replies that it can’t yet propose a legal obligation to keep games playable, and will start talks with the industry and consumer representatives on a code of conduct for games’ “end of life”.
Shaped belief 5
- Now
HyperRogue, a GPL game, sells the same game as its free version, except that “updates are first included in the paid versions”.
Shaped clause 5
Planned first adopter
Mæstræa
Mæstræa is a music workstation that runs on your own computer: a DAW with built-in spatial audio, deep instruments and 50+ local AI model families. It’s in early development by one developer, Æmotion Studio, who started this definition. Nothing is for sale yet; this is how it’s planned to be sold.
Mæstræa is free software under the GNU AGPL-3.0-or-later. You pay for access (official builds, the update channel and support), not for permission. Each official download will come with its source code, and you’re free to share what you get. The name and logo are trademarks, so modified versions must use a different name.
| Clause | The plan |
|---|---|
| Clause 1: A price | At launch: buy once on itch.io, pay what you want with a $15 minimum ($25 suggested), and get every stable 1.x update. Or join the membership at US$8/month on the web (+ applicable tax). |
| Clause 2: Open licence | GNU AGPL-3.0-or-later. A commercial licence is available on request. |
| Clause 3: Source with every copy | Each official download will come with its source code. The development repo isn’t public yet. |
| Clause 4: Nothing held back | There will be no closed editions, and any plugins Æmotion Studio sells will be Sold Open too. The store pages will list the name and logo and the AI models separately. AI models aren’t bundled: each one downloads when you ask for it, mostly from Æmotion Studio mirrors on Hugging Face, and keeps its own licence. Some are non-commercial or research-only. |
| Clause 5: Early, never exclusive | Members will get stable builds about 4 weeks before the public release, and unstable builds as they come out. |
| Clause 6: Sharing is never punished | You’re free to share what you get, early builds included. |
| Clause 7: Nothing switches off | No Mæstræa account and no sign-in to run it. If you cancel a membership, what you downloaded stays yours. |
| Clause 8: Plain terms | The store pages will say all of this, including how buyers will get the source, and that the development repo isn’t public yet. |
Use it
Use the name and the badge
No permission needed. Sold Open is a description, not a trademark: use the name and badge while your copies meet the clauses, and stop if they don’t. Host the badge yourself, so nobody tracks your visitors.
<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="101" height="32" viewBox="0 0 100.73 32" role="img"><title>Sold Open</title><path d="M9.75 .75H96.98a3 3 0 0 1 3 3v24.5a3 3 0 0 1-3 3H9.75L.95 16Z" fill="#c8102e" stroke-linejoin="round"/><circle cx="11.6" cy="16" r="3.3" fill="none" stroke="#ffffff" stroke-width="1.6" stroke-dasharray="16.2 4.5" transform="rotate(-40 11.6 16)"/><path d="M26.57 23.89Q25.64 23.89 25.02 23.58Q24.4 23.27 24.04 22.68Q23.68 22.09 23.53 21.26Q23.38 20.43 23.38 19.39L25.6 19.18Q25.6 19.69 25.64 20.15Q25.68 20.62 25.78 20.99Q25.88 21.37 26.07 21.59Q26.27 21.81 26.57 21.81Q27.07 21.81 27.28 21.34Q27.49 20.87 27.49 20.21Q27.49 19.55 27.15 18.84Q26.8 18.12 26.32 17.48Q25.5 16.39 24.88 15.45Q24.27 14.52 23.93 13.62Q23.59 12.71 23.59 11.73Q23.59 10.95 23.79 10.29Q23.99 9.64 24.37 9.15Q24.75 8.66 25.3 8.39Q25.85 8.11 26.55 8.11Q27.42 8.11 28.02 8.41Q28.63 8.7 29 9.25Q29.37 9.79 29.55 10.55Q29.72 11.3 29.72 12.21L27.49 12.42Q27.49 12.03 27.46 11.64Q27.42 11.24 27.33 10.92Q27.23 10.59 27.05 10.39Q26.87 10.19 26.59 10.19Q26.15 10.19 25.98 10.57Q25.81 10.94 25.81 11.62Q25.81 12.5 26.29 13.32Q26.76 14.14 27.56 15.23Q28.51 16.52 29.12 17.61Q29.72 18.69 29.72 20Q29.72 20.83 29.54 21.54Q29.36 22.25 28.98 22.77Q28.6 23.3 28 23.59Q27.41 23.89 26.57 23.89ZM34.46 23.89Q33.51 23.89 32.83 23.44Q32.16 23 31.8 22.25Q31.43 21.49 31.43 20.55V11.45Q31.43 10.5 31.8 9.75Q32.16 9 32.83 8.56Q33.51 8.11 34.46 8.11Q35.4 8.11 36.08 8.56Q36.76 9 37.12 9.75Q37.48 10.51 37.48 11.45V20.55Q37.48 21.49 37.12 22.25Q36.76 23 36.08 23.44Q35.4 23.89 34.46 23.89ZM34.46 21.68Q34.88 21.68 35.05 21.33Q35.21 20.98 35.21 20.55V11.45Q35.21 11.02 35.03 10.67Q34.86 10.32 34.46 10.32Q34.07 10.32 33.88 10.67Q33.7 11.02 33.7 11.45V20.55Q33.7 20.98 33.88 21.33Q34.06 21.68 34.46 21.68ZM39.66 23.72V8.28H41.92V21.62H44.93V23.72ZM46.45 23.72V8.28H48.76Q49.85 8.28 50.61 8.64Q51.37 9 51.83 9.86Q52.29 10.72 52.49 12.22Q52.7 13.72 52.7 16.01Q52.7 18.31 52.49 19.81Q52.29 21.3 51.83 22.16Q51.37 23.01 50.61 23.37Q49.85 23.72 48.76 23.72ZM48.72 21.45Q49.56 21.45 49.91 20.79Q50.25 20.13 50.33 18.9Q50.4 17.67 50.4 15.98Q50.4 14.27 50.33 13.05Q50.25 11.84 49.9 11.2Q49.55 10.55 48.72 10.55ZM61.62 23.89Q60.67 23.89 59.99 23.44Q59.32 23 58.95 22.25Q58.59 21.49 58.59 20.55V11.45Q58.59 10.5 58.95 9.75Q59.32 9 59.99 8.56Q60.67 8.11 61.62 8.11Q62.56 8.11 63.24 8.56Q63.92 9 64.28 9.75Q64.64 10.51 64.64 11.45V20.55Q64.64 21.49 64.28 22.25Q63.92 23 63.24 23.44Q62.56 23.89 61.62 23.89ZM61.62 21.68Q62.04 21.68 62.2 21.33Q62.37 20.98 62.37 20.55V11.45Q62.37 11.02 62.19 10.67Q62.02 10.32 61.62 10.32Q61.23 10.32 61.04 10.67Q60.86 11.02 60.86 11.45V20.55Q60.86 20.98 61.04 21.33Q61.22 21.68 61.62 21.68ZM66.82 23.72V8.28H69.08Q70.37 8.28 71.24 8.85Q72.11 9.42 72.54 10.46Q72.97 11.5 72.97 12.9Q72.97 14.31 72.52 15.33Q72.07 16.35 71.2 16.92Q70.33 17.49 69.08 17.54V23.72ZM69.08 15.23Q69.68 15.23 70.03 15Q70.37 14.76 70.53 14.25Q70.68 13.73 70.68 12.92Q70.68 12.1 70.53 11.59Q70.37 11.08 70.02 10.83Q69.67 10.59 69.08 10.59ZM74.81 23.72V8.28H79.99V10.61H77.08V14.77H79.18V17.04H77.08V21.39H79.99V23.72ZM82.27 23.72V8.28H84.4L86.5 16.33L86.68 17.04H86.81V8.28H88.89V23.72H86.98L84.67 15.67L84.48 14.96H84.35V23.72Z" fill="#ffffff"/></svg>
<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="101" height="32" viewBox="0 0 100.73 32" role="img"><title>Sold Open</title><path d="M9.75 .75H96.98a3 3 0 0 1 3 3v24.5a3 3 0 0 1-3 3H9.75L.95 16Z" fill="none" stroke="#141414" stroke-width="1.5" stroke-linejoin="round"/><circle cx="11.6" cy="16" r="3.3" fill="none" stroke="#141414" stroke-width="1.6" stroke-dasharray="16.2 4.5" transform="rotate(-40 11.6 16)"/><path d="M26.57 23.89Q25.64 23.89 25.02 23.58Q24.4 23.27 24.04 22.68Q23.68 22.09 23.53 21.26Q23.38 20.43 23.38 19.39L25.6 19.18Q25.6 19.69 25.64 20.15Q25.68 20.62 25.78 20.99Q25.88 21.37 26.07 21.59Q26.27 21.81 26.57 21.81Q27.07 21.81 27.28 21.34Q27.49 20.87 27.49 20.21Q27.49 19.55 27.15 18.84Q26.8 18.12 26.32 17.48Q25.5 16.39 24.88 15.45Q24.27 14.52 23.93 13.62Q23.59 12.71 23.59 11.73Q23.59 10.95 23.79 10.29Q23.99 9.64 24.37 9.15Q24.75 8.66 25.3 8.39Q25.85 8.11 26.55 8.11Q27.42 8.11 28.02 8.41Q28.63 8.7 29 9.25Q29.37 9.79 29.55 10.55Q29.72 11.3 29.72 12.21L27.49 12.42Q27.49 12.03 27.46 11.64Q27.42 11.24 27.33 10.92Q27.23 10.59 27.05 10.39Q26.87 10.19 26.59 10.19Q26.15 10.19 25.98 10.57Q25.81 10.94 25.81 11.62Q25.81 12.5 26.29 13.32Q26.76 14.14 27.56 15.23Q28.51 16.52 29.12 17.61Q29.72 18.69 29.72 20Q29.72 20.83 29.54 21.54Q29.36 22.25 28.98 22.77Q28.6 23.3 28 23.59Q27.41 23.89 26.57 23.89ZM34.46 23.89Q33.51 23.89 32.83 23.44Q32.16 23 31.8 22.25Q31.43 21.49 31.43 20.55V11.45Q31.43 10.5 31.8 9.75Q32.16 9 32.83 8.56Q33.51 8.11 34.46 8.11Q35.4 8.11 36.08 8.56Q36.76 9 37.12 9.75Q37.48 10.51 37.48 11.45V20.55Q37.48 21.49 37.12 22.25Q36.76 23 36.08 23.44Q35.4 23.89 34.46 23.89ZM34.46 21.68Q34.88 21.68 35.05 21.33Q35.21 20.98 35.21 20.55V11.45Q35.21 11.02 35.03 10.67Q34.86 10.32 34.46 10.32Q34.07 10.32 33.88 10.67Q33.7 11.02 33.7 11.45V20.55Q33.7 20.98 33.88 21.33Q34.06 21.68 34.46 21.68ZM39.66 23.72V8.28H41.92V21.62H44.93V23.72ZM46.45 23.72V8.28H48.76Q49.85 8.28 50.61 8.64Q51.37 9 51.83 9.86Q52.29 10.72 52.49 12.22Q52.7 13.72 52.7 16.01Q52.7 18.31 52.49 19.81Q52.29 21.3 51.83 22.16Q51.37 23.01 50.61 23.37Q49.85 23.72 48.76 23.72ZM48.72 21.45Q49.56 21.45 49.91 20.79Q50.25 20.13 50.33 18.9Q50.4 17.67 50.4 15.98Q50.4 14.27 50.33 13.05Q50.25 11.84 49.9 11.2Q49.55 10.55 48.72 10.55ZM61.62 23.89Q60.67 23.89 59.99 23.44Q59.32 23 58.95 22.25Q58.59 21.49 58.59 20.55V11.45Q58.59 10.5 58.95 9.75Q59.32 9 59.99 8.56Q60.67 8.11 61.62 8.11Q62.56 8.11 63.24 8.56Q63.92 9 64.28 9.75Q64.64 10.51 64.64 11.45V20.55Q64.64 21.49 64.28 22.25Q63.92 23 63.24 23.44Q62.56 23.89 61.62 23.89ZM61.62 21.68Q62.04 21.68 62.2 21.33Q62.37 20.98 62.37 20.55V11.45Q62.37 11.02 62.19 10.67Q62.02 10.32 61.62 10.32Q61.23 10.32 61.04 10.67Q60.86 11.02 60.86 11.45V20.55Q60.86 20.98 61.04 21.33Q61.22 21.68 61.62 21.68ZM66.82 23.72V8.28H69.08Q70.37 8.28 71.24 8.85Q72.11 9.42 72.54 10.46Q72.97 11.5 72.97 12.9Q72.97 14.31 72.52 15.33Q72.07 16.35 71.2 16.92Q70.33 17.49 69.08 17.54V23.72ZM69.08 15.23Q69.68 15.23 70.03 15Q70.37 14.76 70.53 14.25Q70.68 13.73 70.68 12.92Q70.68 12.1 70.53 11.59Q70.37 11.08 70.02 10.83Q69.67 10.59 69.08 10.59ZM74.81 23.72V8.28H79.99V10.61H77.08V14.77H79.18V17.04H77.08V21.39H79.99V23.72ZM82.27 23.72V8.28H84.4L86.5 16.33L86.68 17.04H86.81V8.28H88.89V23.72H86.98L84.67 15.67L84.48 14.96H84.35V23.72Z" fill="#141414"/></svg>
<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="101" height="32" viewBox="0 0 100.73 32" role="img"><title>Sold Open</title><path d="M9.75 .75H96.98a3 3 0 0 1 3 3v24.5a3 3 0 0 1-3 3H9.75L.95 16Z" fill="#ededea" stroke-linejoin="round"/><circle cx="11.6" cy="16" r="3.3" fill="none" stroke="#131312" stroke-width="1.6" stroke-dasharray="16.2 4.5" transform="rotate(-40 11.6 16)"/><path d="M26.57 23.89Q25.64 23.89 25.02 23.58Q24.4 23.27 24.04 22.68Q23.68 22.09 23.53 21.26Q23.38 20.43 23.38 19.39L25.6 19.18Q25.6 19.69 25.64 20.15Q25.68 20.62 25.78 20.99Q25.88 21.37 26.07 21.59Q26.27 21.81 26.57 21.81Q27.07 21.81 27.28 21.34Q27.49 20.87 27.49 20.21Q27.49 19.55 27.15 18.84Q26.8 18.12 26.32 17.48Q25.5 16.39 24.88 15.45Q24.27 14.52 23.93 13.62Q23.59 12.71 23.59 11.73Q23.59 10.95 23.79 10.29Q23.99 9.64 24.37 9.15Q24.75 8.66 25.3 8.39Q25.85 8.11 26.55 8.11Q27.42 8.11 28.02 8.41Q28.63 8.7 29 9.25Q29.37 9.79 29.55 10.55Q29.72 11.3 29.72 12.21L27.49 12.42Q27.49 12.03 27.46 11.64Q27.42 11.24 27.33 10.92Q27.23 10.59 27.05 10.39Q26.87 10.19 26.59 10.19Q26.15 10.19 25.98 10.57Q25.81 10.94 25.81 11.62Q25.81 12.5 26.29 13.32Q26.76 14.14 27.56 15.23Q28.51 16.52 29.12 17.61Q29.72 18.69 29.72 20Q29.72 20.83 29.54 21.54Q29.36 22.25 28.98 22.77Q28.6 23.3 28 23.59Q27.41 23.89 26.57 23.89ZM34.46 23.89Q33.51 23.89 32.83 23.44Q32.16 23 31.8 22.25Q31.43 21.49 31.43 20.55V11.45Q31.43 10.5 31.8 9.75Q32.16 9 32.83 8.56Q33.51 8.11 34.46 8.11Q35.4 8.11 36.08 8.56Q36.76 9 37.12 9.75Q37.48 10.51 37.48 11.45V20.55Q37.48 21.49 37.12 22.25Q36.76 23 36.08 23.44Q35.4 23.89 34.46 23.89ZM34.46 21.68Q34.88 21.68 35.05 21.33Q35.21 20.98 35.21 20.55V11.45Q35.21 11.02 35.03 10.67Q34.86 10.32 34.46 10.32Q34.07 10.32 33.88 10.67Q33.7 11.02 33.7 11.45V20.55Q33.7 20.98 33.88 21.33Q34.06 21.68 34.46 21.68ZM39.66 23.72V8.28H41.92V21.62H44.93V23.72ZM46.45 23.72V8.28H48.76Q49.85 8.28 50.61 8.64Q51.37 9 51.83 9.86Q52.29 10.72 52.49 12.22Q52.7 13.72 52.7 16.01Q52.7 18.31 52.49 19.81Q52.29 21.3 51.83 22.16Q51.37 23.01 50.61 23.37Q49.85 23.72 48.76 23.72ZM48.72 21.45Q49.56 21.45 49.91 20.79Q50.25 20.13 50.33 18.9Q50.4 17.67 50.4 15.98Q50.4 14.27 50.33 13.05Q50.25 11.84 49.9 11.2Q49.55 10.55 48.72 10.55ZM61.62 23.89Q60.67 23.89 59.99 23.44Q59.32 23 58.95 22.25Q58.59 21.49 58.59 20.55V11.45Q58.59 10.5 58.95 9.75Q59.32 9 59.99 8.56Q60.67 8.11 61.62 8.11Q62.56 8.11 63.24 8.56Q63.92 9 64.28 9.75Q64.64 10.51 64.64 11.45V20.55Q64.64 21.49 64.28 22.25Q63.92 23 63.24 23.44Q62.56 23.89 61.62 23.89ZM61.62 21.68Q62.04 21.68 62.2 21.33Q62.37 20.98 62.37 20.55V11.45Q62.37 11.02 62.19 10.67Q62.02 10.32 61.62 10.32Q61.23 10.32 61.04 10.67Q60.86 11.02 60.86 11.45V20.55Q60.86 20.98 61.04 21.33Q61.22 21.68 61.62 21.68ZM66.82 23.72V8.28H69.08Q70.37 8.28 71.24 8.85Q72.11 9.42 72.54 10.46Q72.97 11.5 72.97 12.9Q72.97 14.31 72.52 15.33Q72.07 16.35 71.2 16.92Q70.33 17.49 69.08 17.54V23.72ZM69.08 15.23Q69.68 15.23 70.03 15Q70.37 14.76 70.53 14.25Q70.68 13.73 70.68 12.92Q70.68 12.1 70.53 11.59Q70.37 11.08 70.02 10.83Q69.67 10.59 69.08 10.59ZM74.81 23.72V8.28H79.99V10.61H77.08V14.77H79.18V17.04H77.08V21.39H79.99V23.72ZM82.27 23.72V8.28H84.4L86.5 16.33L86.68 17.04H86.81V8.28H88.89V23.72H86.98L84.67 15.67L84.48 14.96H84.35V23.72Z" fill="#131312"/></svg>
<a href="https://soldopen.org/"><img src="sold-open-badge.svg" alt="Sold Open" width="101" height="32"></a>
[](https://soldopen.org/)
Save the SVG next to your page, link the badge to this definition, and say which version you meet: “Sold Open v0.2”.
Maker’s checklist
Three checks for buyers
Transcript of Three checks
[A cardboard parcel tied with paper twine, the red Sold Open badge as its tag. Text: “Three checks for buyers”.] Nobody certifies Sold Open. Anyone can check a claim.
[Eight tiles, one per clause of the definition, version 0.2. Tiles 2, 3 and 7 turn red.] Of its eight promises, three you can check yourself.
[A large red 1. A cardboard box’s flaps fold open. Inside are two folders, “Example App 1.4 · Build” and “Example App 1.4 · Source”. Text: “Open the download.”] One. Open the download.
[The Source folder’s cover opens on pages of printed code. A red outline is drawn round its label.] Is the source in it, or right beside it?
[A large red 2. A licence sheet named “GPL-3.0-or-later”, marked “OSI-approved or FSF-listed”. Text: “Read the licence’s name.”] Two. Read the licence’s name. Is it an open licence?
[Text: “Readable. Isn’t open.”] Readable isn’t open.
[A large red 3. A desk lamp clicks on. Text: “Run it.”] Three. Run it. Does anything check whether you paid?
[A list appears line by line: no activation, no licence keys, no logins, no online checks.] No activation, no licence keys, no logins, no online checks.
[The numerals 1, 2 and 3 beside the badge. The red drains out of the 2, and the badge fades.] If one fails, that copy isn’t Sold Open.
[End card: the badge, “The Sold Open Definition · version 0.2 (draft)”, “Read the definition”, soldopen.org, “Started by Æmotion Studio”.] Read the other five in the definition.
- Open the download. Is the source in it, or right beside it?
- Read the licence’s name. Is it an open licence?
- Run it. Does anything check whether you paid?
Questions
Questions people ask
Isn’t this open-washing, or just a paywall?
Open-washing borrows the word “open” while holding back the rights. Sold Open holds back none of them for the software: the maker charges for it, and after that every buyer has the complete source and may publish it, change it or resell it. Content such as art and music may carry its own terms, listed where it’s sold. To check a claim yourself, use the three buyer checks.
Why name something the FSF already endorses?
The FSF endorses the practice: “Selling a copy of a free program is legitimate, and we encourage it” (Selling Free Software). It doesn’t give it a name. A short name lets makers make the promise in two words and lets buyers check it. Sold Open also adds promises no licence makes, such as a three-month cap on how long other buyers wait, and no activation. Neither the FSF nor the OSI has endorsed Sold Open.
What stops one buyer posting everything?
Nothing, and that’s allowed. The GPL FAQ says so plainly: “someone could pay your fee, and then put her copy on a web site for the general public.” Sold Open needs enough people to pay, not everyone. People pay for the official build, updates, early access and support, and to keep the work going.
If anyone can share it, why would anyone pay?
Most people want the official build from the maker, updates as they land, and someone to ask when it breaks. They also want the next version to exist. Ardour has worked this way for years. Sold Open doesn’t need everyone to pay.
Isn’t this just Ardour?
Ardour is the closest precedent: a GPL audio workstation with paid builds and no licence keys. Sold Open names that pattern so games, apps and plugins can adopt it and say so in two words. One difference runs the other way: Ardour publishes its source for everyone, while Sold Open allows the source to reach buyers only. If you can publish yours, do.
Won’t this confuse people about what open source means?
Not if makers follow one rule: unless your source is public, say “Sold Open” rather than “open source” where people expect public code. The reasons are in Is it open source if you pay to get it?
The FSF advises against “selling software”. Why “Sold”?
The FSF’s worry is that “people usually associate the term ‘selling software’ with proprietary restrictions on the subsequent use of the software” (Words to avoid). Sold Open puts both halves in the name: “Sold” is the fee, and “Open” rules out the restrictions.
Can a game be Sold Open if its art and music aren’t open?
Yes, if everything of yours that runs or decides is open, and the content’s terms are stated where it’s sold. Content is what you see or hear; scripts, shaders, prompts and anything else that runs or decides count as software. Classic open-source game releases often took this shape: open code, separately licensed data.
Can I sell on Steam, the App Store or consoles?
On Steam, yes, if your Steam copy runs without Steam and includes its source; itch.io and your own site work too. On the App Store and consoles, often not, because their rules make some clauses impossible. You can still sell there, but leave the name and badge off those copies and point to your Sold Open copy.
Can a Sold Open maker also sell commercial licences?
Yes. That is a sale of permission, but not one any buyer needs, because using, changing and sharing always come with the software. A commercial licence lets someone use the code without the open licence’s conditions, for example inside a closed product. Say so in plain terms (clause 8).
Could a Sold Open project go closed later?
Its future versions could: a copyright holder can change the licence of what they release next. Nothing already sold can be taken back, and anyone can carry on from it, as LibreSprite did from Aseprite’s last GPL-licensed code. Good practice is to promise notice before any licence change.
Who decides what counts, and who wrote this?
Nobody certifies Sold Open. The definition is the test, and anyone can check a claim against it. It was started by Æmotion Studio, the solo developer of Mæstræa, which is planned to be sold this way, so read it with that in mind. It’s a draft, and corrections are welcome.